Skip to content

Mechanical vs. Hydraulic: Choosing the Best for Metal Shearing

The Importance of Choosing the Right Metal Shearing Instruments

The importance of metal shearing as a key aspect of metal processing cannot be overstated. It is not only about changing the shape of metal materials, but also involves many aspects such as metal reuse, recycling and productivity improvement. In the industrial field, metal shear technology is widely used in automobile manufacturing, construction, machinery manufacturing, aerospace and electronic equipment and other industries, become an indispensable link to promote industrial development.

Mechanical metal shears and hydraulic metal shears are two major metal shearing methods, each of them has unique characteristics and applicable scenarios. Mechanical metal shears rely on mechanical force to cut, simple structure, easy maintenance, fast cutting speed, suitable for large-scale, high-efficiency metal shearing needs. Hydraulic metal shear machine, on the other hand, through the hydraulic cylinder to generate a strong force to cut, although relatively slow, but its shear force, suitable for cutting the thickness of larger or harder metal materials. This type of machine is often used to handle thicker sheet metal or jobs that require higher shearing forces, so we need to emphasize the need to choose the right type of metal shear.

mechanical machine

Mechanical Metal Shears

Working principle and structural characteristics

Mechanical metal shear is the use of mechanical transmission and shear principle for cutting metal materials. Its working principle mainly includes the following steps:

The motor drives the mechanical transmission system (such as gears, cranks, etc.) to rotate, generating mechanical force.

The mechanical force is transmitted to the shear blade through the transmission system, so that the blade exerts a shearing force on the workpiece.

The workpiece is placed on the table and clamped by the shear blade and presser foot. As the shear blade descends, the workpiece is sheared.

Mechanical transmission system: including motor, gear drive, crank mechanism, etc.

Cutting parts: including upper knife, lower knife, presser foot, etc.

Working table: used to support the workpiece and keep the workpiece stable.

mechanical Guillotine-shear-how-it-works

Structural composition and introduction of key components

Motor: provide power source.

Gear transmission: convert the rotary motion of the motor into the linear motion of the shear blade.

Crank mechanism: Convert the rotary motion into the up and down motion of the shear blade.

Upper and lower knives: used to clamp and shear the workpiece.

Pressure foot: Used to fix the workpiece to prevent it from moving during the shearing process.

Advantage analysis

Simple structure: the structure of the mechanical metal shear is relatively simple, easy to manufacture and maintain.

Fast cutting speed: the mechanical transmission system enables the shear blade to fall quickly, improving the shearing efficiency.

Suitable for mass production: due to the fast shearing speed, it is suitable for large-scale, high-efficiency metal shearing needs.

Disadvantage analysis

Noisy: mechanical transmission will produce noise, affecting the working environment.

Energy efficiency is relatively low: due to mechanical transmission will have energy loss, energy efficiency is relatively low compared to the hydraulic metal shear.

Higher material requirements: mechanical metal shear on the hardness and thickness of the workpiece has certain requirements, can not cut too hard or too thick material.

DA360T shearing machine

Hydraulic metal shear

Working principle and structural characteristics

Hydraulic metal shear is a use of hydraulic transmission principle, through the high-pressure liquid drive shear mechanism to achieve rapid and efficient shear of metal materials, special equipment. Its core structure mainly includes a power source, control logic valve, transmission mechanism, shear mechanism and worktable and other major parts. The power source is usually provided by the hydraulic pump station, through the control logic valve to distribute and regulate the flow direction and pressure of the hydraulic oil, so as to drive the transmission mechanism, so that the shear mechanism in accordance with the preset cycle of shear operation.

Advantage analysis

  1. power source: usually consists of electric motor, hydraulic pump, oil tank, etc., is responsible for providing stable high-pressure hydraulic oil flow.
  2. control logic valves: including directional control valves, pressure control valves and flow control valves, etc., responsible for regulating and controlling the flow direction, pressure and flow of hydraulic oil, so as to realize the various actions of the shear.
  3. transmission mechanism: through gears, bearings, connecting rods and other components of the hydraulic energy into mechanical energy, drive the shear mechanism for shearing action.
  4. shear mechanism: including blade, knife seat, guide device, etc., is to realize the key part of the metal shear. Blades are usually made of high-strength wear-resistant materials, with high shear strength and wear resistance.

Analysis of disadvantages

  1. large energy consumption: hydraulic metal shears need to consume a large amount of electricity and hydraulic oil to provide power, so the energy consumption is large, the cost is high.
  2. high maintenance costs: due to the complexity of the hydraulic transmission system, the need for regular replacement of hydraulic oil, cleaning hydraulic components and other maintenance work, so the maintenance cost is high.
  3. Large noise: hydraulic metal shears will produce large noise in the working process, the working environment and the operator has a certain impact.
  4. High quality requirements for oil: the hydraulic transmission system requires high quality of hydraulic oil, you need to use high cleanliness, good anti-wear hydraulic oil, otherwise it is easy to cause wear and tear of hydraulic components and failure.
Shear-Fund-mechanical

Comparison of mechanical and hydraulic metal shears

Performance Comparison

Mechanical metal shears usually convert the rotary motion of the motor into the linear reciprocating motion of the shear mechanism through the transmission mechanism, and use the blades to shear the metal. Its structure is simple, direct action, so it has a high shearing speed and precision. Hydraulic metal shear is the use of hydraulic transmission system to drive the shear mechanism, through the expansion and contraction of the hydraulic cylinder to realize the shear action. Hydraulic transmission has a larger torque and stable shear force, so it is suitable for cutting thicker or harder metal.

Cost Comparison

In terms of initial investment cost, mechanical metal shears are usually less expensive because of their relatively simple structure and lower manufacturing cost. Hydraulic metal shears, on the other hand, are relatively more expensive because they need to be equipped with a hydraulic system and have a higher manufacturing cost. However, in terms of long-term operating costs, hydraulic metal shears have relatively low maintenance costs due to their stable shearing force and less wear and tear.

Comparison of Applicable Scenarios

Mechanical metal shears are suitable for scenarios that require high shearing speed and precision, such as the shearing and processing of thin sheet metal. In addition, the mechanical shear also has a smaller footprint and lower noise, suitable for the higher requirements of the working environment of the occasion. Hydraulic metal shears, on the other hand, are suitable for shearing thicker or harder metals, such as the dismantling and recycling of scrap cars. In addition, hydraulic shears have a larger shearing force and greater adaptability to cope with a variety of complex shearing needs.

Hydraulic Electrical-System

The advantages of hydraulic shearing machine

CNC system's compensation function and automatic detection

The machine is equipped with these additional functions, which can automatically adjust during the cutting process to ensure the cutting precision of the sheet metal. For example, during cutting, if there are changes in material thickness or hardness, the CNC system will automatically adjust the position of the tool and cutting pressure to maintain the required dimensions and shapes.

High-precision rear gauge control

 Utilizing a computer-controlled rear gauge servo system with precision ball screw drive. This means that when cutting different sizes and shapes of workpieces, the machine can precisely control the position of the rear gauge, ensuring cutting accuracy and consistency.

Rolling material support ball device

This device not only reduces frictional resistance but also protects the workpiece surface from scratches. Especially for cases where a high-quality surface finish of the workpiece is required, this design ensures that the workpiece is not damaged during the cutting process.

Strong structure and integrity

The hydraulic shearing machine has strong rigidity and integrity, with flexible and reliable motion of rolling guide rails. The brush material support surface reduces noise, while the pneumatic clamping system provides vertical rear support on the large table, making the machine more stable and reliable during operation.

Blade frame design

The mounting surface of the blade on the blade frame is curved, ensuring uniform blade clearances and improving the quality of the sheared section. This design ensures that the edges of the cut workpieces are smooth and neat.

Material stop structure

The material stop is driven by a motor, moving two lead screws synchronously through sprockets. This structural design makes the fixation of workpieces more reliable and flexible, preventing the workpiece from shifting or shaking during cutting, thus ensuring cutting precision and stability.

Conclusion

Mechanical metal shears and hydraulic metal shears each have their own advantages and disadvantages. Mechanical shears have the advantages of simple structure, low price, high shearing speed and high precision, suitable for scenes with high requirements for shearing speed and precision. Hydraulic shears, on the other hand, have the advantages of large shearing force, adaptability and lower long-term operating costs, suitable for shearing thicker or harder metals.

When choosing a metal shearing method, key factors to consider include the thickness and hardness of the metal material, shear speed and accuracy requirements, working environment and floor space constraints. In addition, factors such as the maintenance cost and service life of the equipment also need to be considered.

About Us

Durmapress specializes in designing, manufacturing and selling various metal processing equipment, including bending machines, shears, punches, laser cutting machines, etc. The company was founded in 2000. With years of experience and technology accumulation. DurmaPress has become one of the well-known brands in China's metal processing machinery industry.

Contact Us

Recent Posts

Categories

Follow Us

Weekly New Video

Contact us for more information

If you have any information about our products, please contact us and we will reply within 24 hours.

ru_RURussian
WeCreativez WhatsApp Support
Our customer support team is here to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
👋 Hi, how can I help?